Please enable JavaScript to properly view our site.

LancLife

Here's what we found in our archives about the Rendezvous Steak Shop

  • 2 min to read
Rendezvous closing

The Rendezvous Steak Shop owner Roger Gaspari talks inside the shop at 239 W. King St. in Lancaster city. His brother Romolo was the first owner of the shop. 

This story contains links that will take you to our archives site on newspapers.com. This content is free for LancasterOnline subscribers who are logged in. Click here for more information about how to subscribe.

With the announcement this week that Rendezvous Steak Shop, a longtime downtown take-out staple, was set to close by the end of the year, we decided to take a look through the LNP | LancasterOnline archives to see what memories we could unearth about this local favorite spot.

We looked at articles, old photos, ads - whatever we could get our hands on.

Here's what we found.


The newspapers' first reference to the
shop was on April 17, 1951

Legal notice

The above legal notice appeared in the New Era, announcing that the name Rendezvous Steak Shop had been registered in Harrisburg, and that the business was planned to open at 242 W. King St.


The Rendezvous' first ad in the paper
appeared on Oct. 7, 1951

Early Rendezvous ad

This small ad didn't say much, but it already began to establish the reputation the Rendezvous would eventually have as a great place for a late-night shack. "For a treat after the movies," the ad says, and goes on to tout the fact that the shop is open "every evening."


The shop had a softball team in 1960

Rendezvous softball

Not much appears in the LNP archives about the Rendezvous softball team, but on Aug. 20, 1960, the Intelligencer Journal published this brief item, which reported the defeat of the Beer Barons at the hands of the Rendezvous team. The Rendezvous pitchers were none other than "Beans" Gaspari, aka shop owner Romolo Gaspari, and his brother Roger.


In 1965, the Rendezvous claimed to
have "the only real Italian pizza" in town

Rendezvous pizza ad

This ad from October, 1965, touts the fact that the owners recently took a trip to Italy and returned with a bunch of new authentic recipes. though the Rendezvous was known as a steak shop, its owner was clearly proud of their pizza as well.


In 1978, an Intelligencer Journal writer spent a whole day working at the Rendezvous

Rendezvous 1978

Salvatore Lucidonio stretches a ball of dough for a pizza at the Rendezvous Steak Shop in 1978.

Nancy Rogers helped out at the sub and pizza shop for a day, learning to stretch pizza dough, chop onions and work a fast-paced lunch counter. She spent the day under the watchful eye of Salvatore Lucidonio, a jack-of-all-trades who kept the shop running.

Check out the full account of her experience here.


That 1978 article also contained some old prices - so let's reminisce

Rendezvous 1978 (2)

Kathy Pichler makes a sub sandwich at the Rendezvous Steak Shop in 1978.

Rendezvous owner Roger Gaspari spoke about the prices back in the 1950s, when the shop opened. Steak sandwiches sold for 25 cents, pizzas for 50 or 65 cents, and Cokes for 5 or 10 cents. At the time of the 1978 article, sandwiches ranged from $1.10 to $1.90, pizzas were $2 or $3.65, and Cokes were 30 or 45 cents. 


They used to give away giant Christmas stockings

Rendezvous Christmas ad

From at least 1980 through 1983, the Rendezvous held drawings for three giant Christmas stockings each year. Ads appeared in all of the Lancaster newspapers promoting the contests for those years.

Do you have your own memories of the Rendezvous? Share them in the comments section, and check out other local residents memories here.

Cuisine

Nostalgia

225 Years

Antiques

History

Architecture

Puzzles

Visit Lancaster