It’s not every day that a church makes an event out of burning important paperwork.

But after 28 years of paying off its mortgage, Mount Calvary Evangelical Lutheran Church in Manheim Township has cause for celebration. The church will host a Mortgage Burning Celebration on Sunday morning for its congregation.

“There is a quiet excitement as we reflect upon the commitment of past members who gave their time and money to build God’s house and look forward to the future,” says Nancy Marshall, event and board of education chair.

The Rev. Christopher Seifferlein, pastor of the church, expresses admiration for parishioners who gave generously and rose to the challenge that predates his arrival at the church. For decades, in addition to their regular weekly offering, members used a special envelope to give monthly toward paying off the mortgage.

“It’s humbling that while as a pastor, I stand joyously at the finish line. It was the hard work of those who came before me for this momentous occasion,” Seifferlein says.

Mount Calvary 2.jpg

Rev. Christopher Seifferlein, right, and longtime church member Nancy Marshall of Mount Calvary Evangelical Lutheran Church, are pictured with an old church bell that once was atop their church when it was located in Lancaster city many years ago on Friday, April 23, 2021.


Building the church

Mount Calvary Evangelical Lutheran Church purchased 7.1 acres on Petersburg Road in Manheim Township in March 1988. The land, which cost $278,000, was paid for in cash. The building’s construction was funded with a 20-year $738,000 mortgage in 1993 through the Lutheran Church Extension Fund. Previously, the church was located at Plum and Clay streets in Lancaster.

Groundbreaking for the 13,400-square foot one story building took place March 21, 1993. Laborers for Christ, a former ministry of the LCEF, built the church. The laborers were a group of dedicated Christian men and women who volunteered some of their retirement to work for Lutheran Church Missouri-Synod ministries. For eight months, spring through fall, these skilled volunteers from around the country parked their RVs at the worksite where they lived and toiled until the project was done.

“Each workday began with Bible study,” Marshall says.

Church members joined the workers with grateful hearts and helping hands. Those unable to do physical labor provided snacks or cleaned up the worksite each evening for the next day’s work.

“Before the drywall was done and carpeting laid in the chancel, members wrote Bible verses on the wood studs and flooring to give praise to God for past and current members who were motivated to plan, give and build the new church,” Marshall says.

Construction was completed in November 1993 and the new building was dedicated on Dec. 5, 1993. Six stained glass windows were moved from the former church building and installed in the new sanctuary. The building housed offices, classrooms, nursery, kitchen and restrooms.


A community effort

The church hosted several fundraising campaigns throughout the years to aid in paying the mortgage, including two Venture Forward in Faith campaigns: the first chaired by Harry Shaub and the second by Ron Marshall, both deceased. Their efforts were followed by a Growing in Faith fundraiser when the building was complete, which raised $392,138.

In 2003, the church refinanced the mortgage to include $185,000 to add 2,000 square feet to the facility for an Evangelism wing. In January 2021, the church paid off the remaining mortgage amount — $530,862 — in full.

“It was a big achievement. Sadly, people who worked so hard on fundraising like Ron passed on before seeing the mortgage paid off,” says Farley Fry, a 21-year member who serves on the event committee.

He commends Marshall on her leadership of the six-member committee that also includes Sheila Ginder, Barry Walton, Kenny Holton and Seifferlein. Past clergy, former members, architects and others involved in the original building design have been invited to the celebration. The event begins at 9 a.m. with a PowerPoint presentation created by Holton, which chronicles Mount Calvary’s history.

At 9:30 a.m., a Service of Praise and Thanksgiving to God will feature Sunday school children who will sing “We are the Church” and a song written by Linda Myers, “Venture Forward in Faith.” Myers is a former member whose ancestors were charter church members.

The mortgage will be burned safely in a brazier. Those participating in the mortgage burning are: Rod Stiegler, congregation chair who will ignite the document; Barry Walton, head trustee; Marilyn Taylor, former member; Marv Trim, past treasurer; Allan Morehead, past chairman; Seifferlein and Marshall. Refreshments will be available while attendees hear comments from those involved in the building project. Memorabilia like an old church bell, a 1930s child’s chair, a 1911 Baptismal Certificate and more will be on display.

Mount Calvary 3.jpg

The sanctuary of Mount Calvary Evangelical Lutheran Church, is pictured where the church will hold an upcoming mortgage burning ceremony after paying off their mortgage on Friday, April 23, 2021.


Looking ahead

As the church celebrates its past, its members also look ahead to the future with a relatively new pastor.

Seifferlein was installed on Nov. 16, 2019, after serving as pastor at Emmanuel Lutheran Church, Adell, Wisconsin, for 14 years. His degrees include Concordia University, River Forest, Illinois (now Concordia Chicago), and Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, Indiana.

“Pastor Seifferlein is the most worship-oriented pastor I’ve ever met. He’s totally focused on worshipping God,” Fry says.

With the pandemic, Seifferlein saw an increase in people needing pastoral care. He says his shut-in list quadrupled for those needing visitation and home communion.

“It’s been a wonderful challenge and joy to use my pastorate to bring true balm and restoration to hurting souls,” Seifferlein says.

Though in-person worship stopped in March 2020, Seifferlein says he feels fortunate to have learned to know congregants before COVID-19 closed the church doors. Audio services became and remain available through the church’s YouTube channel. In May 2020, in-person Sunday worship resumed with the church following CDC guidelines. An additional Wednesday night service helped to reduce people attending on Sunday.

Seifferlein lives in Landisville with his wife Erin and six children Claire, 18; Lillian, 16; Isabel, 14; August, 12; Theodore, 8; Frederick, 5.

What to Read Next