Editor's note: This article was originally published in July, 2019

Lancaster’s first-ever Independent Retail Week is set for next week, with more than 70 businesses offering special deals and promotions.

It’s a great time to look back at a few of the independent retailers that have served customers in downtown Lancaster over the past century and a half.

Here is a small sample of retailers that no longer exist in the city.

leinbach & co. postcard

This undated postcard shows the interior of Leinbach & Co., Lancaster's "daylight department store." 

1. Leinbach & Co., 35-47 N. Queen St.

This large retail establishment, known as the “daylight department store” because of its skylights and open courtyard plan, was founded in 1893 by W. Scott Leinbach. It closed in 1949.

In 1919, employees honored Leinbach and his wife at closing time with a loving cup and flowers on the business’ anniversary, according to LNP archives.

In 1898, 75 dozen H&S corsets were reduced from 89 cents to 59 cents each at Leinbach's. And in 1938, "Miss Hollywood" pajamas were 98 cents and 30 styles of white shoes "to set the town talking" were on sale for $1.99 a pair.

2. John H. Troup Music House, 38-40 W. King St.

The music house, which sold records, phonographs, pianos and other musical instruments, and offered music lessons, was originally established in Harrisburg. It was run by the family of “Route 66” songwriter Bobby Troup, who left Lancaster to seek his fortune in show business in California.

He was also an actor, appearing in the 1970s TV show “Emergency.”

The music house operated in Lancaster from before 1920 through at least the 1950s.

In December 1924, the local Troup store carried Brunswick Christmas records for 75 cents apiece, and in 1928 you could buy an Ampico Symphonique baby grand piano for $1,300.

Bike shop

The staff of the former A. Leaman Futer bicycle shop, creator of the Futer Flyer,  stands outside the shop at 24-26 E. Chestnut Street in this undated file photo.

3. A. Leaman Futer, 140-42 N. Christian St. and East Chestnut Street.

The day after his 20th birthday in 1896, A. Leaman Futer went into the bicycle business in Lancaster, Futer recalled in a 1940 Sunday News story.

In the 1890s, Futer developed a new style of bike, with coaster brakes, called the Futer Flyer.

He and his brother, B. Franklin “Frank” Futer, made and sold the bikes, for $25 in 1900, from a factory at 140-42 N. Christian St.

The shop later moved to the first block of East Chestnut Street.

Sayres, Scheid & Sweeton

The Sayres, Scheid & Sweeton Store on East King Street closed in 1995.

4. Sayres, Scheid & Sweeton, 28-30 E. King St.

Known by some as the 3-S store, this venerable retailer was one of the go-to stores in town for good quality men’s clothing. E.P. Sayres, William F. Scheid and J. Frank Sweeton, who had worked with each other for years at the nearby Williamson and Foster, store opened the shop in 1907.  Three generations of Jere Bortzfield’s family later ran the store; Bortzfield closed it in 1995 amid tough competition from large department stores.

Scheid, the last surviving member of the group of original founders, died in 1972 at age 96.

According to the archives, suits and overcoats cost $25-$28 in 1908. A $50,000 fire in the building destroyed a lot of merchandise in 1909. Kuppenheimer suits cost $40-$60 in 1930, and were billed as “an investment in good appearance.”

Remember when: Readers share memories of Park City's past

Winky Dink Toy Store

In this May 1964 file photo, Winky Dink’s Toy Store appears on the right side of the first block of Lancaster’s West King Street. Other stores in the photo include the former Harold’s furniture, Locher’s Cut Rate and Watt & Shand department store.

5. Winky Dink Toy Store, 16 W. King St.

If you were thinking about holiday gifts in November 1963, Winky Dink Toys was the place to be.

According to the store's ad in the New Era, you could buy games such as Password, The Barbie Game and Candy Land for $1 to $3, an Erector Set for $3, Barbie clothes for 66 cents, a football for $2, an Etch-a-Sketch for $4 or the Kenner Give-a-Show Projector for $5.

Ouija boards had been reduced from $3 to $2.23.

And customers interested in getting holiday toys for workplaces, schools and churches were encouraged to see Bill Winkelman at the store to find out special prices for toys for Christmas parties.

cottons 2.jpg

Suzanne Cotton, left, and Laura Cotton opened the punk shop State of Confusion on West King Street in the 1980s.


6. State of Confusion, 49 W. King St.

In 1984, the Cotton sisters — Suzanne, 17, and Laura, 20 — opened State of Confusion at the site of the former Manhattan Peanut Stand.

The store catered to fans of punk, New Wave and heavy metal bands, selling buttons, wristbands, posters, T-shirts and other clothing.

Suzanne Cotton went on to become a fashion designer, according to a 1990 fashion story in the Sunday News, and later an associate professor and chair of fashion design at Columbus College of Art & Design in Ohio.

Fahnestock ad

This ad for Fahnestock's store on East King Street comes from the Dec. 19, 1870, Intelligencer Journal. The store was a precursor to M.T. Garvin's department store.


7. Fahnestock’s store, East King Street.

Before there was Garvin’s, there was Fahnestock’s.

Back in 1851, according to the Saturday Express in Lancaster, Fahnestock’s store at the southwest corner of North Queen and Orange streets, was run by Return E. Fahnestock,

“Among our merchants, particularly in the dry goods line, no name was better known than that of R.E. Fahnestock,” the retailer’s obituary in the Oct. 2, 1895, Semi-Weekly New Era, said.

The obit called him “fair, honorable and upright” in his business dealings, and said his “character was without blemish. “His whole life was devoted to business.”

Fahnestock eventually moved his store next to the county courthouse on East King Steet.

“Physical infirmities” and “loss of his eyesight” caused Fahnestock to retire in 1883, selling the store to his former store manager, Milton Thomas Garvin, who continued the business as M.T. Garvin & Co.

For more Lancaster nostalgia: 

What to Read Next